Forum Topic

Extinction Rebellion, or XR, has direct links to Momentum - no surprises there.The Bollinger Bolsheviks who do not work have caused misery for those who can't afford a couple of weeks off to wag their fingers at those who do work to pay for those "activists" on benefits.  Retailers are losing millions, with idling cars and lorries causing more pollution, and a sharp rise in taxi use for those who cannot take time off for a yoga session on Waterloo Bridge.  At a time when Hammersmith Bridge, overseen by a Labour Council, is out of action, this is metropolitan suicide, facilitated by Comrade Khan.It is always easy to blame China and India, however a whole front-page article in the FT recently outlined Germany's damnable environmental legacy in continuing to pour out coal-fired pollution near the Polish border.  75% of flying insects have disappeared in Germany.Speaking to friends from "the developing World" they tell me that huge environmental efforts are being quietly made, in countries where political decisions are effected  quickly.  That is why they are developing faster than Europe.Here in the Middle East, water is a precious commodity, and huge advances are being made in hydroponics and dairy farming, to avoid flying in foodstuffs from afar.  There are eco-cities being built where showers turn off automatically after three minutes. In the UK /EU these decisions and projects would take decades to materialise."Global Warming" has morphed into "Climate Change" where by its very nature climate is constantly changing, not least due to solar flare and sunspot activity, and the reversal of iron ore in the Earth's core, a bit like a football team changing ends at half-time, impacting significantly on the weather.  That's why we had Frost Fairs on the Thames not that long ago.While most species are expert at adapting to gradual increases in temperature, it is actually habitat loss that has caused their extinction.  Perhaps these eco-warriors would prefer an Ice-Age, which actually did wipe out everything on the face of the earth.There are scientists, and there are Government Scientists.One of the XR activists said he had seven children, and was "really concerned for their future"  Perhaps he or his wife should have had their tubes tied after the second child, as the real threat to the planet is rampant over-population.I can guarantee that most of the scrub-faced post-meno women turning themselves into human pretzels on Waterloo Bridge, have in the past delivered their multiple offspring to school in gas-guzzling four-wheel drives.  Now their nests are empty, their new hobby is berating others for not walking to school.  There was plenty of organic falafel and apple juice being delivered to the faithful, in plastic bags and bottles, which the rest of us will have to pay to clear up.Emma Thompson, who flies to and fro from Hollywood (presumably not in a hot-air balloon) was on tap in her dungarees to tell us in her best Mockney accent that "There is no Planet B" Another woman wearing a suit (with a nose-ring), had set up a private limited company called "Compassionate Revolution Ltd," based in the Cotswolds, after flying to S America and Africa where large doses of hallucinogenic drugs had caused an epiphany indicating that she had to Save the Planet -  yes, all of it, now.Well there are plenty of opportunities on the doorstep.  The Royal Parks alone have all sorts of eco-projects on the go, and great fun they are too - no graffiti spray  required.  No media coverage either.The planet will do fine without us, we just need to save ourselves from the jibbering Glasto-on-Thames set.  Meanwhile, the real eco-warriors are out at the weekends, not causing mayhem, just quietly tidying up our green spaces and beaches.  Why don't the XR brigade save money on Superglue and join them?

Chantal Blake-Milton ● 2764d

Yes, very happily for 20 years on and off, returning to SW15 regularly.  Look up the Masdar City Project in Abu Dhabi, who have the money in place because they invested their oil dollars wisely, unlike the UK. These are no "vanity projects" and I shudder at the sneering ignorance of the real Middle East when I return "home".  These are the people who built the pyramids whilst we built Stonehenge, so I think they know a little about construction, having built the tallest building on earth on sand, and a vast new airport whilst we talk about a strip of tarmac off the M4.The Wimmin on the bridge would be well advised to bend down occasionally and pick up litter, like those wonderful souls I see on Putney Common at weekends, and yes, some who spout Green now were happily driving large broods to School in the first four-wheel drives.  There are loads of interesting projects to help the environment, like the yellow ant survey I volunteered for in Richmond Park.  No traffic jams, no yoga, just important data quietly gathered on how these tiny critters are vital in moving large amounts of earth around, subsequently assessed by an Oxford don.My daughter takes part in regular beach clean-ups in Hong Kong, where there is a serious issue with the plastic we dump on China, mainly due to lucrative tariffs paid to the container owners.  How will XR address this particular issue?As Attenborough says, the problem with the rainforest and many other areas is "islandisation" once promoted by some environmentalists, disastrously concentrating species into the centre of areas of remaining trees, where survival of the fittest prevails.  Loss of animal habitat and human over-population is the biggest threat we face.It is up to greater powers than us to change industrial emissions, but we can all do our bit by being wise consumers.  How do the critics imagine that the contents of Waitrose arrive in the High Street?  Are they going to give up tropical fruit and coffee for the cause?Those pondering about frost-fairs should remember that we only have records which begun a blink of the eye ago.  I have visited glaciers in Iceland to see for myself how they disappeared about 11,000 years ago, although much smaller now than 1,000 years ago.  This can measured by looking at terminal moraine at the snout of the glacier.The city of Dwarka in India's Gulf of Kutch is testament to a great city that was submerged around 11,000 years ago, and has been kept quiet about because it doe not fit the "Climate Change" narrative.  Mammoth molars have been found by Dutch dredgers in the English Channel, where they once grazed, so "global warming" has happened before, and will happen again.Solar activity controls our temperatures, as does the orbit of the moon, so most of us cannot control the climate, but we can manage waste.  Don't buy single-use plastic, carry a linen shopping bag, support UK farmers - you know the drill.  The best way to lobby those with the power to make change is via online petitions, which actually have impacted on Monsanto etc. - you just never hear about them. The XR brigade do not care for the planet, or anyone else, just grand-standing for their personal 15 minutes of fame, at massive inconvenience to others, forgetting that some people are simply unable to walk long distances, forced to breathe in pollution that they have caused.  Uber is laughing all the way to the bank. As for Mr Carter, his mind appears to be as contradictory as the XR mandate, and he will have to reflect on the wisdom of posting a photoshopped image of Rees-Mogg with a Hitler moustache on a public forum, whilst berating David Lammy for calling the same man a Nazi.  Those who profess their love for the planet the loudest, are often not very nice to their neighbours.

Chantal Blake-Milton ● 2764d

We saw a film about the Masdar City project some time ago and wondered about the lack of shade shown in the visualisations. There were children cycling but that I presume was in the cooler months.  Masdar City is an example of the application of western technology to the problem of living comfortably in a hot climate whereas as you point out there is a very long tradition in the Arab world of using natural technologies to create appropriate living conditions including of course in the Emirates the famous wind tower houses which were largely subject to demolition by the Emirate authorities until fairly recently.  There are wonderful instances of comfortable urban design for example in the now horribly fraught city of Sanaa in the Yemen which could provide a much better model for low energy living than other imported examples.By the way your suggestion that there are no vanity projects in the Emirates is bizarre in the context of the Burj tower.  Why would this undoubtedly amazing technological achievement by mainly western engineers be considered as anything but a vanity project when it has no possible relationship to dealing with the local climatic conditions when land is available in large amounts and where the accommodation could be provided in low rise buildings in a much more ecologically sensitive way?It is a shame that the philosophy of extremists in our time leads to the demonisation of people that you don't agree with when surely good intentions even if you think misled should be applauded and dialogue engaged with rather than the use of persistent pejorative language.

Philippa Bond ● 2764d