Forum Topic

To help understanding, I turned to Google

"Zionism was originally a minority political belief within Jewish communities when it emerged in the late 19th century. While the idea of a spiritual return to Zion (Jerusalem) has been central to Judaism for centuries, the modern political movement to establish a secular Jewish state in Palestine faced significant opposition or indifference from a majority of Jews, particularly in Western Europe and the United States, who largely favored assimilation, as well as from many Orthodox groups who viewed it as a theological violation. Origins as a Minority Movement Late 19th-Century Context: Emerging in response to intense antisemitism in Europe (specifically Russian pogroms), Zionism was initially a minority movement of intellectuals and Eastern European "Lovers of Zion" (Ḥovevei Ẕiyyon).Opposing Views: Before the 1930s, many Jewish groups were actively anti-Zionist, promoting alternative solutions to persecution, such as socialist integration or cultural autonomy in their home countries.Early 20th Century: Prior to World War I, Zionism was largely supported by a minority, mainly consisting of activists from Russia and led by Central Europeans. Shift to DominanceZionism gained momentum as a dominant force over the next few decades due to several factors: Antisemitism & Rising Violence: Escalating anti-Semitic violence in Germany, Russia, and Eastern Europe made the Zionist goal of a safe haven more appealing.The Holocaust: The Nazi genocide destroyed the centers of European Jewish life, causing a radical shift in Jewish public opinion toward the necessity of an independent state.British Support: The 1917 Balfour Declaration, where Britain expressed support for a "national home for the Jewish people," gave the movement significant international legitimacy. Evolution of the MovementEven as late as 1939, while the Jewish population in Palestine was growing, Zionist supporters were still a minority of the world's total Jewish population. The transformation from a fringe movement into a mainstream Jewish belief took place gradually, accelerated dramatically by the Holocaust and the subsequent establishment of Israel in 1948."

David Ainsworth ● 34d3 Comments

Balfour didn't do much of the composition of the Declaration."The text of the Balfour Declaration was primarily drafted through a collaborative process in 1917 involving British Zionist leader Chaim Weizmann, Lord Walter Rothschild, and British government officials, including Foreign Secretary Arthur Balfour, Leo Amery, and Lord Milner. After numerous revisions, the final 67-word letter was signed by Balfour on November 2, 1917"Apparently both Amery and Milner were Zionists too.And Balfour:-Arthur Balfour, the former British Prime Minister and Foreign Secretary, made this statement during a House of Commons debate in 1906:"We have to face the facts. Men are not born equal, the white and black races are not born with equal capacities: they are born with different capacities which education cannot and will not change." Historical ContextSouth Africa Debate: Balfour used these remarks to argue that the disenfranchisement of Black people in South Africa was not "immoral," asserting that Europeans must enjoy greater privileges than native inhabitants.White Supremacist Beliefs: Historians often cite these views as evidence of his adherence to scientific racism and white supremacy. He believed that while all men might be equal from "some points of view," it was an "absurdity" to consider African races equal to those of European descent regarding government and the "higher interests of civilisation".Impact on Policy: These supremacist attitudes informed his broader political career, including his support for the Aliens Act of 1905, which restricted Jewish immigration to Britain, and the Balfour Declaration of 1917, which supported a Jewish "national home" in Palestine without consulting the existing Arab majority [90% at the time].Broader Views: He later expressed similar sentiments regarding Middle Eastern populations, writing in 1919 that Zionist aspirations were of "far profounder import" than the desires of the 700,000 Arabs living in Palestine at the time."So nobody asked the Palestinians.

David Ainsworth ● 34d